Review: Independence Harbor Amber Ale

If you have ever strolled down the "aisle of shame" at ALDI, you have likely spotted the patriotic labeling of Independence Harbor Amber Ale. Brewed by Custom Tap Brews (often associated with Rock Wall Brewing) in Rochester, New York, this budget-friendly craft beer aims to punch well above its weight class.

Score: 5.8

The Profile

• Style: American Amber / Red Ale

• ABV: 5.5%

• Appearance: Pours a clear, light golden-to-copper amber with a moderate, frothy head.

The Tasting Experience

The first thing you’ll notice is the honey. While many amber ales rely solely on roasted malts for sweetness, Independence Harbor is specifically an ale with honey added, giving it a distinct floral lift right off the bat.

• Aroma: Toasted multigrain bread and rich oat aromas dominate, with subtle hints of red apple and toffee.

• Palate: It is medium-bodied and surprisingly complex for its price point. You get flavors of caramelized plantain, toasted nuts (almond and hazelnut), and a creamy caramel finish.

• Finish: The finish is clean with a delicate hop bitterness that prevents the honey and malt from becoming cloying.

The Verdict

Is it a world-class microbrew? Perhaps not, but it is a "Best Buy" standout. Tastings.com remarkably awarded it 92 points, highlighting its exceptionally clean fermentation. For roughly $7 a six-pack, it is an easy "yes" for your next backyard hangout or a casual weeknight dinner.